Peer Reviewers

Articles published by Ascarya: Journal of Islamic Science, Culture and Social Studies undergo a rigorous two-way-blind peer review process. All participants—publishers, editors, reviewers, and authors—are expected to adhere to the ethical standards set by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) Core Practices. For detailed policies and practices, please refer to our Publishing Ethics Guidelines.

Guidelines for Authors

Submission to Publishing Process:

  1. Submission:

    • Submit your manuscript through the Ascarya Online Journal System (OJS).
    • Ensure your manuscript adheres to the journal's formatting and submission guidelines.

  2. Initial Check:

    • The editorial team conducts an initial review to ensure the manuscript fits the journal’s scope and adheres to submission guidelines.
    • Manuscripts that do not meet these criteria may be returned to the authors for revision.

  3. Peer Review:

    • Manuscripts passing the initial check are sent for two-way-blind peer review.
    • Two qualified reviewers will evaluate the manuscript and provide feedback.

  4. Review Decisions:

    • Based on reviewers’ feedback, the editor will make one of the following decisions:
      • Accepted (Minor Revisions)
      • Accepted (Major Revisions)
      • Rejected
    • Authors will receive detailed feedback from the reviewers to guide revisions.

  5. Revisions:

    • Authors revise their manuscripts according to the reviewers’ comments.
    • Use the “Track Changes” function in Microsoft Word to document revisions.
    • Submit a Change Note detailing how each comment was addressed.

  6. Final Review:

    • The revised manuscript and Change Note are reviewed by the editorial team.
    • Further revisions may be requested if necessary.

  7. Publication:

    • Once the manuscript meets all requirements, it is scheduled for publication in the journal.

Rating System:

  • Editors rate the reviews based on their completeness and helpfulness for revisions.
  • This helps improve feedback practices and acknowledges critical and constructive reviews.

Guidelines for Reviewers

Step-by-Step Guide:

  1. Sign in to the Ascarya Review System:

    • Click the link in the Peer Review Request email.
    • Sign in using your account credentials.

  2. Download the Manuscript for Review:

    • Go to the Documents tab in the Ascarya Review System.
    • Download the manuscript for review.

  3. Review the Manuscript and Complete the Peer Review Form:

    • Go to the Peer Review Forms tab.
    • Confirm (or decline if unable to review) the review request.
    • Thoroughly read the manuscript.
    • Fill out each section of the Peer Review Form with detailed feedback.

  4. Submit the Completed Peer Review Form:

    • Click the Submit button at the bottom of the Peer Review Form.
    • The Ascarya Journal Publishing Team will evaluate your review.
    • If needed, you may be asked to revise your review to meet our standards.

Ethical Standards:

As a reviewer, you must adhere to the ethical standards outlined by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) Core Practices. Ensure that your feedback is respectful, constructive, and aims to enhance the manuscript's quality.

Recognition:

Reviewers who successfully complete six reviews within a year will be acknowledged for their valuable contributions and may receive a certificate of appreciation.

Rating System:

Editors will rate the reviews based on their completeness and helpfulness for revisions. This rating system helps improve feedback practices and acknowledges critical and constructive reviews. Reviewers who consistently provide high-quality feedback may receive a certificate of appreciation.